Those that have sought to muddy the waters of climate change have shifted strategies over time.

Firstly we were told it wasn’t happening at all, then the emphasis shifted. We are currently being told, amongst other things, that it isn’t man-made, it is now either

A – A natural cycle

B – Because of the sun

C – Communists

D – Terrorists

Take your pick (I might have made two up there), just don’t blame governments, companies or yourself, keep buying, keep driving, keep flying.

Yesterday, the BBC published the findings of a report that blows at least one of the denial theories away…

[it] concludes that changes in the Sun’s output cannot be causing modern-day climate change.

It shows that for the last 20 years, the Sun’s output has declined, yet temperatures on Earth have risen.

It also shows that modern temperatures are not determined by the Sun’s effect on cosmic rays, as has been claimed.


Dr Lockwood initiated the study partially in response to the TV documentary The Great Global Warming Swindle, broadcast on Britain’s Channel Four earlier this year, which featured the cosmic ray hypothesis.

“All the graphs they showed stopped in about 1980, and I knew why, because things diverged after that,” he told the BBC News website.

“You can’t just ignore bits of data that you don’t like,” he said.

Warming trend

The scientists’ main approach on this new analysis was simple: to look at solar output and cosmic ray intensity over the last 30-40 years, and compare those trends with the graph for global average surface temperature, which has risen by about 0.4C over the period.

Graphs of cosmic ray activity and temperature

Temperatures have continued rising irrespective of cosmic ray flux

The Sun varies on a cycle of about 11 years between periods of high and low activity.

But that cycle comes on top of longer-term trends; and most of the 20th Century saw a slight but steady increase in solar output.

However, in about 1985, that trend appears to have reversed, with solar output declining.

Yet this period has seen temperatures rise as fast as – if not faster than – any time during the previous 100 years.

“This paper reinforces the fact that the warming in the last 20 to 40 years can’t have been caused by solar activity,” said Dr Piers Forster from Leeds University, a leading contributor to this year’s Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change (IPCC) assessment of climate science.

When the ‘Great Global Warming Swindle’ documentary was broadcast it caused an uproar in the scientific community and even some of the people in the documentary claimed that their views were misrepresented.

It was quickly picked up by some in the conspiracy theory category, who seemed to believe it was proof that global warming was a scam designed to put us all under more stringent control. It was also picked up by others in the business community and taken as a sign that it was ok to carry on regardless.

For non-scientists or keen amateurs (like me) it is not too difficult to find out who is funding various groups and therefore see where the interest lies. It is also not difficult to find out who is a genuine expert and who is not. This is why I believe those who say man-made climate change is a reality and not a myth.

Imagine for a moment you read a report by an engineer that, based on accumulated evidence, stated that a car had a serious defect that may cause death or injury. Imagine there was then a huge campaign in order to stop anything being done about it and deny the evidence.

No, wait, thats already happened hasn’t it?

Ok, another example. Imagine you were a doctor and based on years of evidence you knew that smoking was detrimental to health. Imagine then that there was a huge amount of time, money and air time given to studies, using selective evidence, suggesting that smoking wasn’t bad for you at all.

Oh. That already happened too didn’t it.

We are in the same area with global warming (and GM food, but that is another article).

I urge you to read this

The Denial Industry



  1. Fantastic so communists are responsible for all global warming. Has just made my day one of the best excuses for driving a 4×4 in Chelsea yet.

  2. The line of “argument” that says global warming is not caused by us, therefore we don’t have to do anything to mitigate its effects, strikes me as particularly stupid. If I am crossing a road, and suddenly a car appears, approaching at a high speed, I could say that an accident, if it happens, would not be my fault, therefore I don’t need to get out of the way. Even if I’m right, I still end up dead.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s